The Right to a Physical Inspection of Property Before Legal Proceedings Have Commenced

Written by Sam Pennell

Appointing an expert to physically inspect property (such as a motor vehicle) can be of value to insurers being asked to settle third party claims. It’s beneficial for high quantum claims, quantum disputes, and uninsured demands received by an insurer from third party agents.

Acquiring a physical inspection opportunity of property before legal proceedings have commenced will ensure you are best placed to assess third party demands and sufficiently prepared for litigation if/when a dispute arises. Although, these opportunities are sometimes difficult for insurers to obtain or are opposed by the third party and/or their agents.

When proceedings have commenced, the basis to inspect property can be articulated within the pleadings of a Claim or a party’s Defence, which makes the enforceability of legislative provisions relating to the inspection of property less problematic. Such provisions include rule 37.01 of the Magistrates’ Court General Civil Procedure Rules 2020 (VIC) and rule 23.8 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). It’s often less contentious to request an inspection of property during the course of proceedings. It can be more difficult, however, to invoke these provisions before legal proceedings are commenced. So, what should insurers consider when making this request?

Greenberger v Victoria [2008] VSC 357

There were findings on a similar issue in the Supreme Court of Victoria in 2008 during the decision of Greenberger v Victoria [2008] VSC 357 when the preservation of documents before the commencement of proceedings was discussed in the context of rule 37.01 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015 (VIC). This rule is reciprocated in the Magistrates’ Court General Civil Procedure Rules 2020 reg 37.01 which reads:

“In any proceeding the Court may make an order for the inspection, detention, custody or preservation of any property, whether or not in the possession, custody or power of a party.”

In this matter the Court noted that any application brought pursuant to this regulation before proceedings were issued did not require the Court to determine the merits of a particular claim, to not extend their determination beyond merely the inspection, detention, custody or preservation of any property. Instead, it was for the Court to decide that if a person who wishes to inspect the property in circumstances “where proceedings have not been issued (they) must demonstrate existence of an enforceable right, be it legal or equitable or at least an arguable case.”

How to Ensure Your Enforceable Right is Not Overlooked

In order for insurers to give themselves the best opportunity to inspect property, which is the subject of demands they have received, it is important to ensure you are completing the following steps:

  • Ensure early within the claim the third party is made aware of your intention to inspect their property;
  • Where there is suspicion or the possibility of the third party looking to dispose of the property before you have had the opportunity to inspect it, ensure a request is made for this not to occur. Although, this must be considered alongside the possibility there may be resulting storage charges which occur due to your request for the property to not be disposed;
  • Ensure you act promptly when an inspection opportunity is provided by the third party as issues often arise in obtaining a further opportunity if the one provided is missed, or legal proceedings may be commenced.

Key Takeaways

  • There is a right to inspect property before proceedings are commenced if you can demonstrate an enforceable right;
  • The request to inspect property should be made in writing to the owner of the property or their agents/solicitors promptly to ensure it is requested before the property is disposed;
  • If an inspection opportunity is provided on reasonable terms, issues can arise if this opportunity is not utilised.

Should you wish to discuss any of the above, please call Sam Pennell on 03 9947 4543 or one of the Ligeti Partners team members on 03 9947 4500.

Ligeti Partners Contacts

A man smiling, wearing a navy suit and red and blue striped tie, posing for a headshot.

Sam Pennell

Senior Associate

Melbourne

Call Us